Willy T had a really good rookie year here in Houston during their World Series season (finished 2nd to Ryan Howard for Rookie of the Year). But he hasn't done much since.Willy Tavares.
Uh.....new team.....likely old guy....Sheffield already been named.....
Carter also spent a year with the Padres before going to Toronto. And he played his last game at 38.I am guessing Joe Carter but I think he played for 3 teams. (Cubs, Indians, Jays)
I'd like to say I meant to do back-to-back "Pudge" questions, but I didn't...just a coincidence. But yes, Carlton Fisk is right. He had 72 HR's and 282 RBI after turning 40.Fisk?
(I like how you threw in another "Pudge" question)
The hint kind of gives it away.