Rod Carew?
Looking for the active player with the most four-hit games.
(But since you mentioned him, Rod Carew is 5th all-time in four-hit games with 58.)
Rod Carew?
Willy Tavares.
j/k...he blows.
Uh.....new team.....likely old guy....Sheffield already been named.....
Pudge?
I am guessing Joe Carter but I think he played for 3 teams. (Cubs, Indians, Jays)
Fisk?
(I like how you threw in another "Pudge" question)
The hint kind of gives it away.
halladay's got to be one of 'em