Miscellaneous News Thread

You're missing 2 points:
- These were minors; a minor is not expected to make their own decisions all the time, that's why they have parents who are their legal guardians.
- Everyone who is opposed to this decision, characterizes it in a grossly oversimplified way; "she told him to kill himself, so he did". If that were it, there wouldn't be a case. It was much more involved and intense than that, over a long period of time, with someone who was very emotionally entwined.

the girl was the only minor. (i didn't know that until meme posted but it helps my point.) so if a minor isn't expected to make her own decisions all the time aren't you arguing my point that the girl deserves a break?

there is no way to define "emotionally entwined". she was his gf. that may imply an emotional connection but it's certainly not a guarantee. also i really don't think the time matters. if she told him to do it once or told him to do it every day for years it was still his choice. i do not believe anyone, no matter the connection, can simply talk a person into suicide.

Why do y'all know so much about this case?

i've been bitching about this case here for a couple years now. it just really bothers me that this girl was in any sort of legal trouble for her actions. she's a dick, not a criminal.

Do you know anyone that has committed suicide?

Sent from my SM-N910V using Tapatalk

huh, i assumed everyone knew at least 1. i've known 2. the more interesting one was my grandmother, my dad's mom. she was 91 and living in rotterdam in the mid 90's. she had liver cancer and was not going to go through trying to fight it. the doctors said she could probably tough it out for awhile longer but it would be rough. since this was in the netherlands she decided to simply end it. i was a boy at the time but she informed my dad and he flew over to be with her. a doctor came to her home and gave her a quick OD of intravenous morphine with my dad and uncle by her side. she died seconds after the medicine was administered. sad, but also a nice way to call it quits.
 
Last edited:
so if a minor isn't expected to make her own decisions all the time aren't you arguing my point that the girl deserves a break?

i do not believe anyone, no matter the connection, can simply talk a person into suicide.
I'd be fine with sentencing her like a minor.

Teen suicide is very common, and it's nearly always caused by people talking.

How about you find a mentally handicapped person, convince him that there's a big present for him in the middle of a busy highway, and then walk away.
 
There is a big difference between being a tard and being a guy with some problems. Yes if I were to coax a down's kid into walking into the street than I would be criminally at fault. Those people are defenseless. That was not the case with this guy. If he decided to kill a bunch of people instead of himself he would not be tried as insane or unfit. He was a normal guy who clearly had issues.
 
Last edited:
I'd be fine with sentencing her like a minor.

Fair enough.

This brings up a whole other issue where I'm not sure of my stance. I think there should be a cutoff age for trying as an adult...some 11 year old's qualify for adult court right now and that seems wrong to me. Also I think there should be a very specific set of guidelines for what crimes are bad enough to warrant adult court. So I guess I'm in favor of kids being tried as adults in theory but in many cases opposed to the way it is currently practiced.
 
There is a big difference between being a tard and being a guy with some problems. Yes if I were to coax a down's kid into walking into the street than I would be criminally at fault. Those people are defenseless. That was not the case with this guy. If he decided to kill a bunch of people instead of himself he would not be tried as insane or unfit. He was a normal guy who clearly had issues.

So only certain mental disorders should be protected? How is a mentally ill person less protected than someone with downs?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Depression isn't really being mental. People can go about living a normal life while depressed. Those with debilitating, permanent mental issues deserve more help/protection.
 
Last edited:
Depression isn't really being mental. People can go about living a normal life while depressed. Those with debilitating, permanent mental issues deserve more help/protection.

Depression is a mental illness/imbalance. People can live a normal life with the help of medication and doctor's care.

And just to be clear. in this case, she actually talked him back into the car once he was in the act of killing himself and she knew very well he was doing it. It is a bit more than just texting him with bad messages for months (which she also did).
 
But he wasn't, really. We criminalize suicide. And that's why she's in trouble. If his suicide was respected she wouldn't be on trial.

No human is free if they are forced to stay alive.
You're making an absolute, 100% strawman argument. Murder is illegal. End of story. Your soapbox rant about suicide is irrelevant.
 
Rule 1 of the memebag vortex: re-state facts in the form of a question.

So you're not familiar with the term "manslaughter", nor do you know how to look it up?
She was convicted of manslaughter. I'm not asking about that. I think that conviction is based on a twisted view of suicide. But let's not debate that. Was he murdered or did he commit suicide? You say he was murdered but all of the news says he committed suicide. Which is it?
 
Back
Top Bottom