Miscellaneous News Thread

There could be hundreds of people in this man's life who contributed to his suicidal mental state. Singling her out as the only culpable party doesn't seem to have a logical basis.
It's your line of reasoning that doesn't have a logical basis. Of the "hundreds of people in this man's life", she's the only one who was on the phone with him when he got out of the truck - because he decided he couldn't go through with it - and convinced him to get back in the truck and finish the job.

You make these long-winded posts with philosophical arguments, trying to pump-up your point of view, about how you think things should be. But here's how things are:

- The teen suicide rate in the US is high, and nearly all of it can be attributed to social pressure. That's the difference between your theories and the facts.
- The girl was arrested and put on trial, because there was compelling evidence that her contribution to the boy's death was possibly criminal; more so than the thousands upon thousands of instances where no one was arrested; and presumably more so than nearly all of the suicides which have (and are to have) occurred since.
- She was found guilty of a murder-related charge by a judge.
 
It's your line of reasoning that doesn't have a logical basis. Of the "hundreds of people in this man's life", she's the only one who was on the phone with him when he got out of the truck - because he decided he couldn't go through with it - and convinced him to get back in the truck and finish the job.

Right, but hundreds of other people got him to be on the phone with her. If we're going to spread the blame from him to other people, why just her? How did he end up so messed up he would listen to her? Who is responsible for that? If we blame her then we have to blame them, too.

You make these long-winded posts with philosophical arguments, trying to pump-up your point of view, about how you think things should be. But here's how things are:

- The teen suicide rate in the US is high, and nearly all of it can be attributed to social pressure. That's the difference between your theories and the facts.
- The girl was arrested and put on trial, because there was compelling evidence that her contribution to the boy's death was possibly criminal; more so than the thousands upon thousands of instances where no one was arrested; and presumably more so than nearly all of the suicides which have (and are to have) occurred since.
- She was found guilty of a murder-related charge by a judge.

There's no need to be insulting. If you think my posts are too long, just don't read them.

Teen suicide rates have nothing to do with my positions. I'm not arguing teens should kill themselves. I'm arguing two specific things:

1. We can't hold this woman responsible for this man's death.
2. Suicide should be legal.

Neither of those positions are at odds with high teen suicide rates.

I understand this judge made this decision, but I disagree with it. Further, I don't think it will hold up on appeal.

You have stated three facts, but you haven't addressed my arguments. What do you see as the legal basis for involuntary manslaughter in this case? Why should suicide be illegal?
 
There's no need to be insulting. If you think my posts are too long, just don't read them.
I didn't realize you were so sensitive; I'll be more mindful in the future.

I have no problem with posts that are necessarily long, but I felt that your point was mainly about what you believe, which can be summarized by the statement, "people are responsible for their own actions".
Teen suicide rates have nothing to do with my positions. I'm not arguing teens should kill themselves.
You have stated three facts, but you haven't addressed my arguments. What do you see as the legal basis for involuntary manslaughter in this case? Why should suicide be illegal?
You're misinterpreting my facts about teen suicide. Your argument is that social pressure - taunting, bullying, stalking, shaming, coercing, mocking, isolating, threatening, brainwashing - can't make anyone commit suicide. But my point is that those things are nearly always the cause for the thousands of suicides that do occur. So there's a big disconnect between how you think things should be, and how they are.

Her involvement in seeing him dead was no different than other forms of manslaughter. And once again, the legality of suicide has no bearing on this case.
 
I didn't realize you were so sensitive; I'll be more mindful in the future.

Thanks.

I have no problem with posts that are necessarily long, but I felt that your point was mainly about what you believe, which can be summarized by the statement, "people are responsible for their own actions".

This is all just what I believe. I try to include "why" I believe what I believe as well. You know, to support my argument.

You're misinterpreting my facts about teen suicide. Your argument is that social pressure - taunting, bullying, stalking, shaming, coercing, mocking, isolating, threatening, brainwashing - can't make anyone commit suicide. But my point is that those things are nearly always the cause for the thousands of suicides that do occur. So there's a big disconnect between how you think things should be, and how they are.

There's a disconnect between what we believe. I don't think what you believe is "the way things are". I think you are wrong, and I've tried to explain why. Social pressure can contribute to suicide, but that doesn't satisfy the legal requirements for involuntary manslaughter. If she's responsible in this case, why aren't other people responsible? What about people who didn't discourage suicide? How wide a net are we going to cast?

Is Harrison Ford legally guilty for Carrie Fisher's death? When she was 19 and drunk, 39 year old Ford dragged her away from a film crew saying "the lady doesn’t seem to be very aware of what she wants." Then he dragged her to his car and started making out with her. She was an addict who died with coke, heroin and MDMA in her system. Is it Ford's fault? Is it Debbie Reynold's fault?

Her involvement in seeing him dead was no different than other forms of manslaughter. And once again, the legality of suicide has no bearing on this case.

So if suicide were entirely legal and a socially respected act, she would have still been found guilty? Why would she even be on trial in that world?

In Massachusetts, involuntary manslaughter has two forms:

1) An unlawful killing that was unintentionally caused as the result of the defendants' wanton or reckless conduct;
2) An unlawful killing that resulted during the commission of a dangerous battery by a defendant.

Her "involvement in seeing him dead" was speaking words. There was nothing unintentional about them. There was no dangerous battery. Just words.
 
I don't understand any of that. What sort of professional do you want me to talk to? What "vortex" are you talking about?
I'm not taking the bait.

If you're serious, go down to a suicide crisis center (or whatever support agency your community offers) and learn something about it from qualified individuals.

Learn, then report back.
Till then it's a waste of time discussing it with you.


Sent from my SM-N910V using Tapatalk
 
I'm not taking the bait.

If you're serious, go down to a suicide crisis center (or whatever support agency your community offers) and learn something about it from qualified individuals.

Learn, then report back.
Till then it's a waste of time discussing it with you.


Sent from my SM-N910V using Tapatalk
You think I don't know about suicide? Because I want it to be legal? I promise you, I know a lot of about suicide and suicidal ideation. There's no "bait" here. I'm being honest and open with you. I've been close to suicide myself on multiple occasions. My conviction that it should be legal is informed by my own history.
 
So if suicide were entirely legal and a socially respected act, she would have still been found guilty? Why would she even be on trial in that world?

Her "involvement in seeing him dead" was speaking words. There was nothing unintentional about them. There was no dangerous battery. Just words.
There are multitudes of legal things that cannot legally be forced or coerced upon someone. So the "suicide is illegal" argument needs to be dropped, as that has no bearing on the case.

Many crimes involve "just words", I'm sure you can think of some on your own.
 
There are multitudes of legal things that cannot legally be forced or coerced upon someone. So the "suicide is illegal" argument needs to be dropped, as that has no bearing on the case.

Many crimes involve "just words", I'm sure you can think of some on your own.
I can think of "hate speech" and "incitement". I don't think hate speech should be illegal, though. And incitement is only incitement if it results in a crime being committed.

So you believe she forced or coerced him to kill himself?
 
You think I don't know about suicide? Because I want it to be legal? I promise you, I know a lot of about suicide and suicidal ideation. There's no "bait" here. I'm being honest and open with you. I've been close to suicide myself on multiple occasions. My conviction that it should be legal is informed by my own history.
66680154.jpg
 
Hey, with this wonderful new hosting system, I'm trying to post a URL, and it keeps converting it to embedded media, which I then can't see.
 
Back
Top Bottom