Rock 'n Roll HOF announces nominees

They posted Brandi Carlile singing Black Hole Sun with Soundgarden and Jerry Cantrell. As odd as that sounds, she can really belt it out. They also had Taylor Momsen (who I wasn't familiar with) front a few songs. She seemed to be a good choice.
 
I just saw the 2024 ceremony on Hulu this morning. Kind've skipped through a lot but watched all of Dionne Warwick and Jimmy Buffet.
 
I received this email today:

“ TONIGHT! DON'T MISS THE 2025 INDUCTION CEREMONY ON ABC


Tune in tonight to see the 2025 Rock & Roll Hall of Fame Induction Ceremony on ABC. Experience the magic of Induction night with Bad Company, Cyndi Lauper, Soundgarden, and more.

Start the new year off right!
Tonight, at 8/7C on ABC “
 
The November 8 induction ceremony was streamed live on Disney+ and lasted four hours and 25 minutes. Tonight's telecast lasts only three hours – and includes commercials. The complete ceremony is on good ol' YouTube.

 
I received this email today:

“ TONIGHT! DON'T MISS THE 2025 INDUCTION CEREMONY ON ABC


Tune in tonight to see the 2025 Rock & Roll Hall of Fame Induction Ceremony on ABC. Experience the magic of Induction night with Bad Company, Cyndi Lauper, Soundgarden, and more.

Start the new year off right!
Tonight, at 8/7C on ABC “
I'll be watching this. Good background TV.
 
We missed the beginning, but caught most of it.
Even though the Hall sucks, the ceremony is usually pretty good.
 
We missed the beginning, but caught most of it.
Even though the Hall sucks, the ceremony is usually pretty good.
I watched the beginning on TV and thought it was great. It was a tribute to Sly and the Family Stone, starting with a short retrospective, then a live performance. It was a star-packed stage, headed by Stevie Wonder on keyboards. With Flea on bass, Beck on guitar & harmonica, and Questlove on drums.

This is the video of the opening. Watching this now, I see a lot of screw-ups, such as Flea missing his vocal cue. But I swear they dubbed it in on the re-broadcast last night. Also, Questlove is wearing a moo-moo, Stevie Wonder missed a few entrances (I wonder why), and Beck couldn't get the harmonica out of his jacket pocket. And the other lead singers were Maxwell, Leon Thomas, and Jennifer Hudson.

 
This is the video of the opening. Watching this now, I see a lot of screw-ups, such as Flea missing his vocal cue. But I swear they dubbed it in on the re-broadcast last night. Also, Questlove is wearing a moo-moo, Stevie Wonder missed a few entrances (I wonder why), and Beck couldn't get the harmonica out of his jacket pocket. And the other lead singers were Maxwell, Leon Thomas, and Jennifer Hudson.

I suspect that the artitsts likely don't have a lot of run throughs with everybody before the show. Some screwups are to be expected. But for a taped broadcast months later, why wouldn't they redub screwups? Perhaps change camera angles, etc.
 
I suspect that the artitsts likely don't have a lot of run throughs with everybody before the show. Some screwups are to be expected. But for a taped broadcast months later, why wouldn't they redub screwups? Perhaps change camera angles, etc.
The video is of the live performance. My perception of the rebroadcast is that they indeed added an overdub of Flea's missed intro, and probably changed the camera angle.
 
The 2026 nominees – that's the year, not the number of them – for induction into the Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame are Jeff Buckley, P!nk, Mariah Carey, Melissa Etheridge, Billy Idol, Phil Collins, Lauryn Hill, Sade, Shakira, Luther Vandross, Oasis, INXS, Iron Maiden, New Edition, Joy Division/New Order, the Black Crowes and the Wu-Tang Clan. The inductees will be decided by ballots cast by an international panel of more than 1,200 artists, historians and music industry professionals. Votes by fans will also be part of the final tally. Fans can vote at

 
My ratings list

Billy Idol - quite a few great hits, great history and deserves to be in
Bad Company - one or two hits I recognized, great history and deserves to be in
Chubby Checker - one or two hits I recognized, great history and deserves to be in
Cyndi Lauper - quite a few great hits, great history and deserves to be in
Joe Cocker - quite a few great hits, deserves to be in
Joy Division/New Order - quite a few great hits and deserves to be in
Mana - who the fuck are they? :poo:
Mariah Carey - tons of hits but she full of :poo:
Oasis - quite a few great hits, deserves to be in
Outkast - couple of great hits, I would let them in
Phish - nobody gives a :poo:
Soundgarden - quite a few great hits, deserves to be in
The Black Crowes - one or two hits I recognized, guess let them in?
The White Stripes - one or two hits I recognized, shouldn't be nominated!

With last year comments, making it simple.

Deserves to be in
Billy Idol
INXS
Iron Maiden
Joy Division/New Order
Luther Vandross
Oasis
Phil Collins
Pink
Melissa Etheridge
Shakira

Needs to wait
The Black Crowes

:poo:
Mariah Carey
Wu-Tang Clan

Not familiar with their music
Jeff Buckley
Lauryn Hill
New Edition

Only song I know from Sade is Smooth Operator
 
My preference:

Jeff Buckley - yes, but partially because of his untimely death;
P!nk - no;
Mariah Carey - no (but she'll get in);
Melissa Etheridge - yes;
Billy Idol - yes;
Phil Collins - yes;
Lauryn Hill - I thought she was already in, I wouldn't vote for her, but she's had some crazy highly regarded songs;
Sade - no;
Shakira - no;
Luther Vandross - I thought he was in, not a rocker but I guess he deserves it;
Oasis - I guess so, meh;
INXS - yes;
Iron Maiden - I guess so;
New Edition - noooo;
Joy Division/New Order - yes;
the Black Crowes - thought they were in, yes;
Wu-Tang Clan - no.
 
Phil Collins is in as a member of Genesis but he should also be in as a solo artist. Mariah Carey, Billy Idol, Oasis, INXS and the Black Crowes should be in.
 
Jeff Buckley - at some point
P!nk - no;
Mariah Carey - hell no (but she'll get in);
Melissa Etheridge - yes at some point
Billy Idol - hell yes;
Phil Collins - yes;
Lauryn Hill - I thought she was already in, I wouldn't vote for her, but she's had some crazy highly regarded songs; - This
Sade - no;
Shakira - hell no;
Luther Vandross - I thought he was in, not a rocker but I guess he deserves it; eventually
Oasis - I guess so, eventually;
INXS - yes;
Iron Maiden - hell yes
New Edition - noooo;
Joy Division/New Order - yes;
the Black Crowes - eventually
Wu-Tang Clan - no.
 
I have crossed out the ones that are NO. Bolded the ones that should get it (IMHO). The rest are neutral.
Jeff Buckley,
P!nk,
Mariah Carey,

Melissa Etheridge,
Billy Idol,
Phil Collins,

Lauryn Hill,
Sade,
Shakira,
Luther Vandross,

Oasis,
INXS,
Iron Maiden,
New Edition,
Joy Division/New Order,

the Black Crowes
the Wu-Tang Clan.
 
Jeff Buckley (kinda, I mean sympathy over his early death is stopping me from crossing him off, if he were still alive and had faded into obscurity, he'd be nixxed)

P!nk

Mariah Carey


Melissa Etheridge

Billy Idol (AND STEVE STEVENS)

Phil Collins

Lauryn Hill

Sade

Shakira

Luther Vandross

Oasis

INXS

Iron Maiden

New Edition

Joy Division/
New Order

Black Crowes

Wu-Tang Clan
 
Just want to make sure he isn't excluded. When Ozzy got in, did they also include Randy Rhodes, Tommy Aldridge, Rudy Sarzo, Jake E Lee, Carmin Appice, Randy Castillo, Zack Wylde, Mike Inez and Robert Trujuilo?
 
Back
Top Bottom