Rock 'n Roll HOF announces nominees

I guess, I'm much younger then you guys I'm 42 years old. That probably why I hardly listen to older genre music.
 
Is Duran Duran or Eurytmics considered Rock? I always classified them as Pop. (Not bad just not rock).
Putting aside the reality (as we all know) that the RRHOF inducts a lot of folk, country-pop, country-rock, blues, blues-rock, R&B, rap, hip-hop, dance-rock, pop-rock, and plain old pop; I'd say those two bands are as much rock as many other rock bands. What excludes songs like Rio or Would I Lie To You from being classified as "Rock"?
 
I guess, I'm much younger then you guys I'm 42 years old. That probably why I hardly listen to older genre music.
Beck's song Loser is almost 30 years old. He's been making music for the past 30 years (I posted probably 15 hits of his in Scotch Sampler). I understand you're not into him, or you don't come across his music, but it's not because of your age. There are more people of your age who listen to Beck than people of my age.
 
Beck's song Loser is almost 30 years old. He's been making music for the past 30 years (I posted probably 15 hits of his in Scotch Sampler). I understand you're not into him, or you don't come across his music, but it's not because of your age. There are more people of your age who listen to Beck than people of my age.
I guess the people that are around my age is a "Loser" for listening to him. :laugh:
 
From the Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame website: "Artists become eligible for induction 25 years after the release of their first record." Here is what is scary: Nickelback's first single was released in 1996. They're eligible now. By the way, none of their first five singles charted, not even in Canada.
 
Putting aside the reality (as we all know) that the RRHOF inducts a lot of folk, country-pop, country-rock, blues, blues-rock, R&B, rap, hip-hop, dance-rock, pop-rock, and plain old pop; I'd say those two bands are as much rock as many other rock bands. What excludes songs like Rio or Would I Lie To You from being classified as "Rock"?
I guess less reliance on a guitar. I can't explain it. It just doesn't sound like rock to me.
 
Bands like The Cure and Depeche Mode get in, plus hundreds of ballad singers and pure pop acts. So I don't know why anyone would think that you need guitar-heavy rock to get in. You could wish that to be the case, but it hasn't ever been like that.
 
In 1986, the first Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame inductees were Elvis Presley, Chuck Berry, James Brown, Fats Domino, Sam Cooke, Ray Charles, Buddy Holly, Little Richard, Jerry Lee Lewis and the Everly Brothers. Among the great rock'n'roll artists inducted in the 2000s are Jay-Z, Tupac Shakur, NWA, Run-DMC, Public Enemy and the Beastie Boys. What the hey?!?
 
Bands like The Cure and Depeche Mode get in, plus hundreds of ballad singers and pure pop acts. So I don't know why anyone would think that you need guitar-heavy rock to get in. You could wish that to be the case, but it hasn't ever been like that.
I am not saying that. I am saying it should not be called the "Rock N' Roll" Hall of Fame. Call it the Pop HOF or anything else. If you are going to keep the name, only induct rock acts.
 
The Grammy Hall of Fame was established in 1973 and honors "musical recordings of lasting qualitative or historical significance.," everything from ABC and A-Tisket, A-Tasket to Zip-A-Dee-Doo-Dah and Zing! Went The Strings Of My Heart


There is also a Musicians Hall Of Fame & Museum in Nashville:


Who needs that dumb ol' Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame anyway?
 
My silly ol' opinion

Duran Duran - mostly rock, some alt rock ("Too Much Information"), some alternative music ("All She Wants Is")
Eurythmics - started out alternative music, migrated toward rock and alt rock
Cure - mostly alt rock, some alternative music ("The Walk", "More Than This")
Depeche Mode - mostly alternative music/synth pop, slight dabbling in alt rock (ie "Barrel Of A Gun", "Useless")
Jay-Z - not rock
Tupac Shakur - not rock
Run-DMC - sometimes hip hop ("Peter Piper", "Mary Mary"), sometimes rap over samples of rock ("It's Tricky", ), sometimes rap rock ("Tougher Than Leather", "King Of Rock")
NWA - not rock (but often rapped over samples of rock)
Public Enemy - not rock (but sometimes rapped over samples of rock)

I guess less reliance on a guitar. I can't explain it. It just doesn't sound like rock to me.

Rock to me can be without guitars, like Billy Joel and Ben Folds Five for example.
 
From the Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame website: "Artists become eligible for induction 25 years after the release of their first record." Here is what is scary: Nickelback's first single was released in 1996. They're eligible now. By the way, none of their first five singles charted, not even in Canada.
There first album "Hesher" had no real hits. There second album "The State" that came out in 2000 had a couple of hits and somewhat made a name for them. But in 2001 "Silver Side Up" really put them on the map and having way better songs and hits.

I think Nickelback might be accepted after 2025?
 
I am not saying that. I am saying it should not be called the "Rock N' Roll" Hall of Fame. Call it the Pop HOF or anything else. If you are going to keep the name, only induct rock acts.
I kind of agree with IRBS, they keep inducting rap, pop artist. The "Rock N Roll" Hall of Fame should probably be renamed to simply Music Hall of Fame?
 
In 1978, after Dolly had hits with Here You Come Again and Two Doors Down, many of her fans accused her of going pop. She told Country Music magazine, "I couldn't go pop with a mouth full of firecrackers." A cute line – and then she released this disco song:

 
Back
Top Bottom