Rolling Stone's 500 Greatest Albums of All Time

scotchandcigar

All I wanted was some steak
Moving this here. These are the posts so far.
In 2003, Rolling Stone published a list of The 500 Greatest Albums Of All Time. The list was updated in 2012 and on December 31, 2023. In the latest ranking, Pet Sounds is #2. Golly gee, what is number one? I will tell you that it is not Sgt. Pepper's. That ranked #24. Here is the list:

I wonder if a human exists who actually likes all these albums, and in this order. I can't imagine anyone having nearly equal enthusiasm for The Beatles, Kanye West, Radiohead, Joni Mitchell, The Beach Boys, Public Enemy, and Marvin Gaye.
Beyond Kanye West I could probably come closest. Besides him I do listen/have listened to the others.
I looked through the bottom 50 and I have listened to 0 of them. Some of them I have heard songs released from the album. But I likely could list maybe 25 total albums that I have listened to track 01 --> 99. Some of them may be on that list. Maybe somebody whose user name ends in 2 numbers could translate this list to ascii text and post it.
I could do that – but it would be easier (and faster) to post the link to the list that is posted on Wikipedia. You're welcome. Of the bottom 50 albums, I own three: Linda Ronstadt's Heart Like A Wheel, Jefferson Airplane's Surrealistic Pillow and the Rolling Stones' Some Girls.

These ones are ones that I would consider good whole albums. Lots of the list was good albums with lots of good songs but not the whole album. A lot of the list was complete crap too.

7. Rumours
8. Purple Rain
21. Born to Run
46. Graceland
55. The Dark Side Of The Moon (why is this higher than "The Wall"?)
62. Appetite for Destruction
69. Jagged Little Pill
84. Back In Black
112. Goodbye Yellow Brick Road
118. Hotel California
128. A Night At the Opera
129. The Wall
135. The Joshawa Tree
142. Born In The U.S.A.
146. Parallel Lines
163. Saturday Night Fever
164. At Folsum Prison
231. Damn The Torpedos (this one is borderline)
264. Wish You Were Here
298. Full Moon Fever
353. The Cars
361. The Black Parade
375. Dookie
379. Moving Pictures
418. Brothers In Arms
Each of the Monkees' first four albums went to number one and their fifth album reached #3 – and none of them are among that Top 500. Headquarters is one of my favorite albums. Did none of those "300 artists, producers, critics and music-industry figures" ever hear Shades Of Gray?
I have several albums which I consider classics and they are also not on that list. Also the ordering is also suspect in many cases.
One of the few lists where they didn't have a Beatles album #1. I do believe it's the end times. :oops:

Let's continue here.

55. The Dark Side Of The Moon (why is this higher than "The Wall"?)
Dark Side was the top selling album of all time, way before The Wall ever existed. You're looking at it through your "post-1977" lens. Personally, I was preparing for college when The Wall came out. So while I appreciated the effort, it was too "teen angst" for me.

I'm working on my take on the silly top 500 list. Stay tuned.
 
These are the albums in the list that I bought, or that my brother/sister bought and went into my collection. This does not include albums given to me over the years. I think there's 110.

#AlbumArtist(s)
4​
Songs in the Key of LifeStevie Wonder
5​
Abbey RoadThe Beatles
6​
NevermindNirvana
7​
RumoursFleetwood Mac
8​
Purple RainPrince and the Revolution
12​
ThrillerMichael Jackson
16​
London CallingThe Clash
20​
Kid ARadiohead
21​
Born to RunBruce Springsteen
25​
TapestryCarole King
30​
Are You ExperiencedThe Jimi Hendrix Experience
31​
Kind of BlueMiles Davis
33​
Back to BlackAmy Winehouse
34​
InnervisionsStevie Wonder
36​
Off the WallMichael Jackson
39​
Remain in LightTalking Heads
42​
OK ComputerRadiohead
46​
GracelandPaul Simon
52​
Station to StationDavid Bowie
53​
Electric LadylandThe Jimi Hendrix Experience
55​
The Dark Side of the MoonPink Floyd
56​
Exile in GuyvilleLiz Phair
63​
AjaSteely Dan
66​
A Love SupremeJohn Coltrane
69​
Jagged Little PillAlanis Morissette
72​
HarvestNeil Young
77​
Who's NextThe Who
84​
Back in BlackAC/DC
86​
The DoorsThe Doors
87​
Bitches BrewMiles Davis
90​
After the Gold RushNeil Young
91​
Darkness on the Edge of TownBruce Springsteen
96​
Automatic for the PeopleR.E.M.
104​
Sticky FingersThe Rolling Stones
105​
At Fillmore EastThe Allman Brothers Band
110​
Court and SparkJoni Mitchell
112​
Goodbye Yellow Brick RoadElton John
118​
Hotel CaliforniaEagles
121​
This Year's ModelElvis Costello
122​
The Downward SpiralNine Inch Nails
123​
Led Zeppelin IILed Zeppelin
124​
Achtung BabyU2
128​
A Night at the OperaQueen
129​
The WallPink Floyd
130​
1999Prince
135​
The Joshua TreeU2
137​
21Adele
142​
Born in the U.S.A.Bruce Springsteen
144​
Physical GraffitiLed Zeppelin
151​
FaithGeorge Michael
152​
PretendersThe Pretenders
153​
Rid of MePJ Harvey
159​
SynchronicityThe Police
160​
TenPearl Jam
161​
Crosby, Stills & NashCrosby, Stills & Nash
165​
MurmurR.E.M.
167​
ViolatorDepeche Mode
168​
Can't Buy a ThrillSteely Dan
169​
The StrangerBilly Joel
173​
In UteroNirvana
182​
Sweet Baby JamesJames Taylor
189​
Dig Me OutSleater-Kinney
190​
TommyThe Who
194​
BadMichael Jackson
220​
Déjà VuCrosby, Stills, Nash & Young
222​
Ray of LightMadonna
223​
ImagineJohn Lennon
232​
Giant StepsJohn Coltrane
233​
Little EarthquakesTori Amos
248​
American IdiotGreen Day
256​
Tracy ChapmanTracy Chapman
264​
Wish You Were HerePink Floyd
273​
Entertainment!Gang of Four
276​
The BendsRadiohead
279​
MTV Unplugged in New YorkNirvana
293​
Last SplashThe Breeders
295​
Random Access MemoriesDaft Punk
296​
Rust Never SleepsNeil Young and Crazy Horse
297​
SoPeter Gabriel
313​
Stories from the City, Stories from the SeaPJ Harvey
324​
A Rush of Blood to the HeadColdplay
327​
Live at LeedsThe Who
328​
Modern Vampires of the CityVampire Weekend
334​
AbraxasSantana
336​
AvalonRoxy Music
341​
Siamese DreamThe Smashing Pumpkins
342​
Let It BeThe Beatles
345​
The Wild, the Innocent & the E Street ShuffleBruce Springsteen
346​
AMArctic Monkeys
353​
The CarsThe Cars
364​
More Songs About Buildings and FoodTalking Heads
366​
RocksAerosmith
375​
DookieGreen Day
377​
Fever to TellYeah Yeah Yeahs
379​
Moving PicturesRush
382​
CurrentsTame Impala
387​
In RainbowsRadiohead
406​
69 Love SongsThe Magnetic Fields
418​
Brothers in ArmsDire Straits
420​
That's the Way of the WorldEarth, Wind & Fire
421​
ArularM.I.A.
424​
OdelayBeck
433​
Sound of SilverLCD Soundsystem
443​
Scary Monsters (and Super Creeps)David Bowie
445​
Close to the EdgeYes
449​
ElephantThe White Stripes
457​
I Do Not Want What I Haven't GotSinéad O'Connor
475​
Sheryl CrowSheryl Crow
486​
ContinuumJohn Mayer
492​
Nick of TimeBonnie Raitt
500​
FuneralArcade Fire
 
Another 45 albums from the list are in my collection. These were donated to me by various people.

#AlbumArtist(s)
1​
What's Going OnMarvin Gaye
2​
Pet SoundsThe Beach Boys
3​
BlueJoni Mitchell
11​
RevolverThe Beatles
14​
Exile on Main St.The Rolling Stones
24​
Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club BandThe Beatles
35​
Rubber SoulThe Beatles
40​
The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders from MarsDavid Bowie
58​
Led Zeppelin IVLed Zeppelin
59​
Talking BookStevie Wonder
62​
Appetite for DestructionGuns N' Roses
92​
Axis: Bold as LoveThe Jimi Hendrix Experience
98​
Car Wheels on a Gravel RoadLucinda Williams
101​
Led ZeppelinLed Zeppelin
102​
The ClashThe Clash
106​
Live Through ThisHole
108​
When the Pawn...Fiona Apple
109​
TransformerLou Reed
111​
ControlJanet Jackson
120​
MoondanceVan Morrison
141​
DoolittlePixies
143​
The Velvet UndergroundThe Velvet Underground
146​
Parallel LinesBlondie
163​
Saturday Night FeverVarious artists
171​
Daydream NationSonic Youth
172​
Bridge over Troubled WaterSimon & Garfunkel
177​
Every Picture Tells a StoryRod Stewart
198​
The B-52'sThe B-52's
205​
Tea for the TillermanCat Stevens
215​
American BeautyGrateful Dead
231​
Damn the TorpedoesTom Petty and the Heartbreakers
251​
Honky ChâteauElton John
252​
Q: Are We Not Men? A: We Are Devo!Devo
266​
Help!The Beatles
278​
Houses of the HolyLed Zeppelin
298​
Full Moon FeverTom Petty
316​
The Who Sell OutThe Who
323​
Sandinista!The Clash
361​
The Black ParadeMy Chemical Romance
368​
All Things Must PassGeorge Harrison
381​
(Pronounced 'Lĕh-'nérd 'Skin-'nérd)Lynyrd Skynyrd
390​
Surfer RosaPixies
400​
Beauty and the BeatThe Go-Go's
401​
BlondieBlondie
450​
RamPaul and Linda McCartney
468​
Some GirlsThe Rolling Stones

Channel98 said:
Each of the Monkees' first four albums went to number one and their fifth album reached #3 – and none of them are among that Top 500. Headquarters is one of my favorite albums. Did none of those "300 artists, producers, critics and music-industry figures" ever hear Shades Of Gray?

I've been given every Monkees album, but as you say, none of them are on the list.
 
Here is Rolling Stone's original 500 Greatest Albums list, published in 2003. Michael Jackson's Thriller was #20. The Elvis Presley compilation The Sun Sessions was #11. The Beach Boys' Pet Sounds was #2. Number one was.........

 
Here is Rolling Stone's original 500 Greatest Albums list, published in 2003. Michael Jackson's Thriller was #20. The Elvis Presley compilation The Sun Sessions was #11. The Beach Boys' Pet Sounds was #2. Number one was.........

One of the biggest changes is that Blue by Joni Mitchell was #30 in 2003, but moved up to #3 in the updated list. I wonder what would cause a highly-praised but very obscure 1971 album's ranking to rise so much between 30 and 50 years after release. The only two songs I recognize from it are "Carey" and "River".
 
Likewise, Bob Dylan's "Blood on the Tracks", from 1975, contains exactly 2 songs I recognize. "Tangled Up in Blue" made it into the top 40 (just barely). And "Shelter from the Storm" gets some airplay too. But you'd think that for the #9 greatest album of all time, there'd be more to it.
 
I mean, really, the whole thing's a clusterfuck. If you asked a thousand people what the top 10 albums of all time are, how many would include Lauryn Hill (at #10)? It's a nice album, but how seriously should we take a hip-hop album?
 
We know what is the all-time album is here. Drc Madness #13

Pink Floyd "The Wall"

ab67616d0000b2735d48e2f56d691f9a4e4b0bdf



Even though this album should have won with the greatest song on it. :p

71qVC8cybrL.jpg
 
In May 2024, Apple Music published their list of the 100 Best Albums. Marvin Gaye's What's Going On, the Beach Boys' Pet Sounds and Joni Mitchell's Blue – the top three albums on Rolling Stone's 2023 list – were #17, #20 and #16, respectively, on Apple's list. Michael Jackson's Thriller was #2. Number one was.......

 
Wow, #1 for Lauryn Hill. The scrolling of that list is kind of neat, or annoying.

Also, here's the cover of the Kendrick Lamar album.
1749821325422.webp

And here's the cover of a Black Keys album.
1749821311085.webp
 
From the other thread to here

Solid albums (no more than one or two clunker/mediocre songs allowed)

7 Rumours Fleetwood Mac
12 Thriller Michael Jackson
56 Exile in Guyville Liz Phair not for everyone though, this belongs on a list of best indie albums
58 Led Zeppelin IV Led Zeppelin
62 Appetite for Destruction Guns N' Roses
63 Aja Steely Dan
84 Back in Black AC/DC
116 Disintegration The Cure my number one!
124 Achtung Baby U2
125 Paul's Boutique Beastie Boys but it's not for everyone
129 The Wall Pink Floyd
130 1999 Prince
135 The Joshua Tree U2 but like the black album (metallica) i'm sick of about 1/2 of it
159 Synchronicity The Police
167 Violator Depeche Mode
169 The Stranger Billy Joel not on my personal list, but i get it
192 Licensed to Ill Beastie Boys but it's not for everyone
209 Raising Hell Run-DMC but it's not for everyone
233 Little Earthquakes Tori Amos
235 Metallica Metallica but like the achtung baby i'm sick of about 1/2 of it
246 Mama Said Knock You Out LL Cool J but it's not for everyone
292 Van Halen Van Halen
297 So Peter Gabriel
352 The Slim Shady LP Eminem but it's not for everyone
418 Brothers in Arms Dire Straits not as strong as it used to be though
453 Pretty Hate Machine Nine Inch Nails
 
New list. I find it interesting, but I don't think it warrants a new thread. When I have some time, I will offer my thoughts on this list. I will say that, at first glance, it's not terrible; and it includes many truly good songs, representative of the best of the 2000s (IMO). It's not all Drake and people with dollar signs and "lil" in their names. I should also note that many songs on this list are in my favorites posts in Scotch Sampler.


Here's just the list:

The 200 Greatest Rock Songs of the 21st Century So Far - Rolling Stone​

1. Yeah Yeah Yeahs - “Maps” (2003)
2. The White Stripes - “Seven Nation Army” (2003)
3. The Killers - “Mr. Brightside” (2004)
4. Olivia Rodrigo - “Good 4 U” (2021)
5. Radiohead - “The National Anthem” (2000)
6. Phoebe Bridgers - “I Know the End” (2020)
7. The Strokes - “Last Nite” (2001)
8. Jay-Z - “99 Problems” (2003)
9. Arctic Monkeys - “I Bet You Look Good on the Dancefloor” (2005)
10. Wilco - “Impossible Germany” (2007)
11. Foo Fighters - “Times Like These” (2002)
12. Paramore - “That’s What You Get” (2007)
13. Lucy Dacus - “Night Shift” (2018)
14. Rilo Kiley - “Portions for Foxes” (2004)
15. Franz Ferdinand - “Take Me Out” (2003)
16. My Chemical Romance - “Welcome to the Black Parade” (2006)
17. LCD Soundsystem - “All My Friends” (2007)
18. TV On the Radio - “Wolf Like Me” (2006)
19. Mitski - “Your Best American Girl” (2016)
20. Fall Out Boy - “Sugar, We’re Goin Down” (2005)
21. Geese - “Getting Killed” (2025)
22. U2 - “Beautiful Day” (2000)
23. David Bowie - “Blackstar” (2016)
24. Coldplay - “Yellow” (2000)
25. Jimmy Eat World - “The Middle” (2001)
26. The Hives - “Hate to Say I Told You So” (2000)
27. Bruce Springsteen - “The Rising” (2002)
28. Lana Del Rey - “Venice Bitch” (2019)
29. Modest Mouse - “Float On” (2004)
30. Broken Social Scene - “7/4 (Shoreline)” (2005)
31. MJ Lenderman - “Hangover Game” (2022)
32. Sleater-Kinney - “Entertain” (2005)
33. Taylor Swift - “All Too Well (10 Minute Version)” (2021)
34. System of a Down - “Chop Suey!” (2001)
35. MGMT - “Time to Pretend” (2007)
36. Queens of the Stone Age - “No One Knows” (2002)
37. Arcade Fire - “Rebellion (Lies)” (2004)
38. Bob Dylan - “Honest With Me” (2001)
39. Phoenix - “1901” (2009)
40. Slayer - “Disciple” (2001)
41. OutKast - “B.O.B.” (2000)
42. Vampire Weekend - “A-Punk” (2008)
43. Courtney Barnett - “Pedestrian at Best” (2015)
44. The Rapture - “House of Jealous Lovers” (2003)
45. Alabama Shakes - “Hold On” (2012)
46. Beyoncé and Jack White - “Don’t Hurt Yourself” (2016)
47. Deftones - “Change (In the House of Flies)” (2000)
48. The New Pornographers - “Letter From an Occupant” (2000)
49. Weezer - “Hash Pipe” (2001)
50. Red Hot Chili Peppers - “By the Way” (2002)
51. Muse - “Supermassive Black Hole” (2006)
52. My Morning Jacket - “Wordless Chorus” (2005)
53. Alvvays - “Party Police” (2014)
54. PJ Harvey - “This Is Love” (2000)
55. Waxahatchee - “Never Been Wrong” (2017)
56. Panic! at the Disco - “I Write Sins Not Tragedies” (2005)
57. Parquet Courts - “Stoned and Starving” (2012)
58. Blink-182 - “The Rock Show” (2001)
59. D’Angelo and the Vanguard - “The Charade” (2015)
60. Mastodon - “Blood and Thunder” (2004)
61. Fontaines D.C. - “Starburster” (2024)
62. Bloc Party - “Banquet” (2004)
63. Café Tacvba - “Eres” (2005)
64. Car Seat Headrest - “Drunk Drivers/Killer Whales” (2016)
65. Fountains of Wayne - “Mexican Wine” (2003)
66. The Walkmen - “The Rat” (2004)
67. Converge - “Concubine” (2001)
68. Wednesday - “Chosen to Deserve” (2023)
69. The Hold Steady - “Killer Parties” (2004)
70. St. Vincent - “Marrow” (2009)
71. Kelly Clarkson - “Since U Been Gone” (2004)
72. Wheatus - “Teenage Dirtbag” (2000)
73. Tyler Childers - “Eatin’ Big Time” (2025)
74. Turnstile - “Blackout” (2021)
75. Haim - “The Wire” (2013)
76. Kaiser Chiefs - “I Predict a Riot” (2004)
77. Mannequin ***** - “Drunk II” (2019)
78. Jesu - “Star” (2006)
79. The War on Drugs - “Red Eyes” (2014)
80. Maná - “Mariposa Traicionera” (2002)
81. Interpol - “PDA” (2002)
82. Lady Gaga - “Yoü and I” (2011)
83. Radiohead - “There, There” (2005)
84. Wet Leg - “Chaise Longue” (2022)
85. Evanescence - “Bring Me to Life” (2003)
86. Black Keys - “Lonely Boy” (2011)
87. Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds - “Jubilee Street” (2013)
88. Arctic Monkeys - “R U Mine” (2011)
89. Stephen Malkmus - “Real Emotional Trash” (2008)
90. Against Me! - “Transgender Dysphoria Blues” (2014)
91. Tool - “The Grudge” (2001)
92. Green Day - “Holiday” (2004)
93. Fiona Apple - “Horns of a Bull” (2026)
94. Opeth - “Deliverance” (2002)
95. R.E.M. - “Imitation of Life” (2000)
96. Doves - “Black and White Town” (2005)
97. Japanese Breakfast - “Be Sweet” (2021)
98. Natalia Lafourcade - “En el 2000” (2002)
99. Drive-By Truckers - “Marry Me” (2003)
100. The 1975 - “I Always Wanna Die (Sometimes)” (2018)
101. The Roots feat. Cody Chesnutt - “The Seed (2.0)” (2003)
102. The National - “Bloodbuzz Ohio” (2010)
103. Linkin Park - “In the End” (2000)
104. White Stripes - “Ball and Biscuit” (2003)
105. Death Cab for Cutie - “Transatlanticism” (2003)
106. Bartees Strange - “Boomer” (2020)
107. Boygenius - “Stay Down” (2018)
108. The Vines - “Get Free” (2002)
109. Black Sabbath - “God Is Dead?” (2013)
110. Bob Dylan - “Key West (Philosopher Pirate)” (2020)
111. The Darkness - “I Believe in a Thing Called Love” (2003)
112. Brandi Carlile - “The Story” (2007)
113. Elliott Smith - “L.A.” (2000)
114. Pearl Jam - “Got Some” (2009)
115. Gaslight Anthem - “The ’59 Sound” (2008)
116. Willow feat. Travis Barker - “Transparent Soul” (2021)
117. Nine Inch Nails - “The Hand That Feeds” (2005)
118. Silversun Pickups - “Lazy Eye” (2006)
119. Cameron Winter - “Love Takes Miles” (2024)
120. Benjamin Booker - “Violent Shiver” (2014)
121. My Chemical Romance - “I’m Not Okay (I Promise)” (2004)
122. Paul McCartney - “Fine Line” (2005)
123. Taking Back Sunday - “You’re So Last Summer” (2002)
124. John Mayer - “Slow Dancing in a Burning Room” (2006)
125. Gojira - “Flying Whales” (2005)
126. Spoon - “The Way We Get By” (2002)
127. Audioslave - “Like a Stone” (2002)
128. Gary Clark Jr. - “Bright Lights” (2011)
129. Sonic Youth - “Incinerate” (2006)
130. Harry Styles - “Kiwi” (2017)
131. Muse - “Uprising” (2009)
132. Japandroids - “The Nights of Wine and Roses” (2012)
133. Kings of Leon - “The Bucket” (2004)
134. Rush - “Headlong Flight” (2012)
135. The Killers - “Read My Mind” (2006)
136. The Stratford 4 - “Telephone” (2003)
137. Big Thief - “Not” (2019)
138. The Strokes - “Reptilia” (2003)
139. Neil Young and Crazy Horse - “Ramada Inn” (2012)
140. Arch Enemy - “We Will Rise” (2003)
141. Soccer Mommy - “Circle the Drain” (2020)
142. Low Cut Connie - “Revolution Rock n Roll” (2017)
143. Snail Mail - “Heat Wave” (2018)
144. Wolfmother - “Joker & the Thief” (2005)
145. Songs: Ohia - “Farewell Transmission” (2003)
146. Lou Reed - “Big Sky” (2000)
147. The Libertines - “Don’t Look Back Into the Sun” (2003)
148. Yo La Tengo - “Cherry Chapstick” (2000)
149. Meshuggah - “Bleed” (2008)
150. Bleachers - “Jesus Is Dead” (2024)
151. Kurt Vile - “Pretty Pimpin’” (2015)
152. Jet - “Are You Gonna Be My Girl” (2003)
153. Foo Fighters - “Best of You” (2005)
154. Boris with Michio Kurihara - “Rainbow” (2007)
155. Sky Ferreira - “You’re Not the One” (2013)
156. Prince - “Guitar” (2007)
157. Hop Along - “The Knock” (2015)
158. Gossip - “Standing in the Way of Control” (2006)
159. The Shins - “Caring Is Creepy” (2001)
160. Water From Your Eyes - “Barley” (2023)
161. Metallica - “Spit Out the Bone” (2016)
162. Ought - “Beautiful Blue Sky” (2015)
163. Sturgill Simpson - “Call to Arms” (2016)
164. Deerhunter - “Desire Lines” (2010)
165. Louis XIV - “Finding Out True Love Is Blind” (2005)
166. At the Drive-In - “Arcarsenal” (2000)
167. Jason Isbell and the 400 Unit - “Cumberland Gap” (2017)
168. Electric Six - “Danger! High Voltage” (2002)
169. The Rolling Stones - “Whole Wide World” (2023)
170. Sum 41 - “Fat Lip” (2001)
171. Mdou Moctar - “Afrique Victime” (2021)
172. The Monkees - “Me and Magdalena” (2016)
173. Blondshell - “Salad” (2023)
174. Future Islands - “Seasons (Waiting on You)” (2014)
175. Red Clay Strays - “Wondering Why” (2022)
176. King Gizzard and the Lizard Wizard - “Rattlesnake” (2017)
177. Alejandro Escovedo - “Castanets” (2001)
178. Sleigh Bells - “Rill Rill” (2010)
179. Moses Sumney - “Virile” (2019)
180. Downtown Boys - “Monstro” (2015)
181. Yungblud - “Hello Heaven, Hello” (2025)
182. Avril Lavigne - “My Happy Ending” (2004)
183. Bombino - “Amidinine” (2013)
184. Mudcrutch - “Crystal River” (2008)
185. Velvet Revolver - “Slither” (2004)
186. Tame Impala - “Elephant” (2012)
187. Slipknot - “People = ****” (2001)
188. The Raconteurs - “Steady, As She Goes” (2006)
189. Baroness - “Isak” (2007)
190. Alex G - “After Ur Gone” (2014)
191. Wolf Parade - “I’ll Believe in Anything” (2005)
192. Juanes - “Es Por Ti” (2002)
193. Momma - “Speeding 72” (2022)
194. Old 97’s - “Rollerskate Skinny” (2001)
195. The Mountain Goats - “This Year” (2005)
196. Incubus - “Circles” (2001)
197. Mogwai - “2 Rights Make 1 Wrong” (2001)
198. Speedy Ortiz - “The Graduates” (2015)
199. Noah Kahan - “American Cars” (2026)
200. Yellowcard - “Ocean Avenue” (2003)
 
9 good/ok from this 200:

3. The Killers - “Mr. Brightside” (2004)
16. My Chemical Romance - “Welcome to the Black Parade” (2006)
22. U2 - “Beautiful Day” (2000)
24. Coldplay - “Yellow” (2000)
25. Jimmy Eat World - “The Middle” (2001)
27. Bruce Springsteen - “The Rising” (2002)
58. Blink-182 - “The Rock Show” (2001)
72. Wheatus - “Teenage Dirtbag” (2000)
121. My Chemical Romance - “I’m Not Okay (I Promise)” (2004)
 
9 good/ok from this 200:

3. The Killers - “Mr. Brightside” (2004)
16. My Chemical Romance - “Welcome to the Black Parade” (2006)
22. U2 - “Beautiful Day” (2000)
24. Coldplay - “Yellow” (2000)
25. Jimmy Eat World - “The Middle” (2001)
27. Bruce Springsteen - “The Rising” (2002)
58. Blink-182 - “The Rock Show” (2001)
72. Wheatus - “Teenage Dirtbag” (2000)
121. My Chemical Romance - “I’m Not Okay (I Promise)” (2004)
I bet you know a lot more, such as:
92. Green Day - “Holiday” (2004)

But anyway, here's the list, color-coded in green for songs featured or mentioned in my Scotch Sampler favorites, and blue for other songs I'm familiar with and like.

1. Yeah Yeah Yeahs - “Maps” (2003)
2. The White Stripes - “Seven Nation Army” (2003)
3. The Killers - “Mr. Brightside” (2004)

4. Olivia Rodrigo - “Good 4 U” (2021)
5. Radiohead - “The National Anthem” (2000)
6. Phoebe Bridgers - “I Know the End” (2020)
7. The Strokes - “Last Nite” (2001)

8. Jay-Z - “99 Problems” (2003)
9. Arctic Monkeys - “I Bet You Look Good on the Dancefloor” (2005)
10. Wilco - “Impossible Germany” (2007)
11. Foo Fighters - “Times Like These” (2002)
12. Paramore - “That’s What You Get” (2007)
13. Lucy Dacus - “Night Shift” (2018)
14. Rilo Kiley - “Portions for Foxes” (2004)

15. Franz Ferdinand - “Take Me Out” (2003)
16. My Chemical Romance - “Welcome to the Black Parade” (2006)
17. LCD Soundsystem - “All My Friends” (2007)
18. TV On the Radio - “Wolf Like Me” (2006)
19. Mitski - “Your Best American Girl” (2016)

20. Fall Out Boy - “Sugar, We’re Goin Down” (2005)
21. Geese - “Getting Killed” (2025)

22. U2 - “Beautiful Day” (2000)
23. David Bowie - “Blackstar” (2016)
24. Coldplay - “Yellow” (2000)
25. Jimmy Eat World - “The Middle” (2001)

26. The Hives - “Hate to Say I Told You So” (2000)
27. Bruce Springsteen - “The Rising” (2002)
28. Lana Del Rey - “Venice Bitch” (2019)
29. Modest Mouse - “Float On” (2004)
30. Broken Social Scene - “7/4 (Shoreline)” (2005)

31. MJ Lenderman - “Hangover Game” (2022)
32. Sleater-Kinney - “Entertain” (2005)

33. Taylor Swift - “All Too Well (10 Minute Version)” (2021)
34. System of a Down - “Chop Suey!” (2001)
35. MGMT - “Time to Pretend” (2007)
36. Queens of the Stone Age - “No One Knows” (2002)
37. Arcade Fire - “Rebellion (Lies)” (2004)

38. Bob Dylan - “Honest With Me” (2001)
39. Phoenix - “1901” (2009)
40. Slayer - “Disciple” (2001)
41. OutKast - “B.O.B.” (2000)
42. Vampire Weekend - “A-Punk” (2008)
43. Courtney Barnett - “Pedestrian at Best” (2015)

44. The Rapture - “House of Jealous Lovers” (2003)
45. Alabama Shakes - “Hold On” (2012)
46. Beyoncé and Jack White - “Don’t Hurt Yourself” (2016)
47. Deftones - “Change (In the House of Flies)” (2000)
48. The New Pornographers - “Letter From an Occupant” (2000)
49. Weezer - “Hash Pipe” (2001)
50. Red Hot Chili Peppers - “By the Way” (2002)

51. Muse - “Supermassive Black Hole” (2006)
52. My Morning Jacket - “Wordless Chorus” (2005)
53. Alvvays - “Party Police” (2014)

54. PJ Harvey - “This Is Love” (2000)
55. Waxahatchee - “Never Been Wrong” (2017)
56. Panic! at the Disco - “I Write Sins Not Tragedies” (2005)

57. Parquet Courts - “Stoned and Starving” (2012)
58. Blink-182 - “The Rock Show” (2001)
59. D’Angelo and the Vanguard - “The Charade” (2015)
60. Mastodon - “Blood and Thunder” (2004)
61. Fontaines D.C. - “Starburster” (2024)
62. Bloc Party - “Banquet” (2004)
63. Café Tacvba - “Eres” (2005)
64. Car Seat Headrest - “Drunk Drivers/Killer Whales” (2016)
65. Fountains of Wayne - “Mexican Wine” (2003)
66. The Walkmen - “The Rat” (2004)
67. Converge - “Concubine” (2001)
68. Wednesday - “Chosen to Deserve” (2023)
69. The Hold Steady - “Killer Parties” (2004)
70. St. Vincent - “Marrow” (2009)
71. Kelly Clarkson - “Since U Been Gone” (2004)
72. Wheatus - “Teenage Dirtbag” (2000)
73. Tyler Childers - “Eatin’ Big Time” (2025)
74. Turnstile - “Blackout” (2021)
75. Haim - “The Wire” (2013)
76. Kaiser Chiefs - “I Predict a Riot” (2004)
77. Mannequin ***** - “Drunk II” (2019)

78. Jesu - “Star” (2006)
79. The War on Drugs - “Red Eyes” (2014)
80. Maná - “Mariposa Traicionera” (2002)
81. Interpol - “PDA” (2002)
82. Lady Gaga - “Yoü and I” (2011)
83. Radiohead - “There, There” (2005)
84. Wet Leg - “Chaise Longue” (2022)
85. Evanescence - “Bring Me to Life” (2003)
86. Black Keys - “Lonely Boy” (2011)

87. Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds - “Jubilee Street” (2013)
88. Arctic Monkeys - “R U Mine” (2011)
89. Stephen Malkmus - “Real Emotional Trash” (2008)
90. Against Me! - “Transgender Dysphoria Blues” (2014)

91. Tool - “The Grudge” (2001)
92. Green Day - “Holiday” (2004)
93. Fiona Apple - “Horns of a Bull” (2026)
94. Opeth - “Deliverance” (2002)
95. R.E.M. - “Imitation of Life” (2000)
96. Doves - “Black and White Town” (2005)
97. Japanese Breakfast - “Be Sweet” (2021)

98. Natalia Lafourcade - “En el 2000” (2002)
99. Drive-By Truckers - “Marry Me” (2003)
100. The 1975 - “I Always Wanna Die (Sometimes)” (2018)
 
101. The Roots feat. Cody Chesnutt - “The Seed (2.0)” (2003)
102. The National - “Bloodbuzz Ohio” (2010)
103. Linkin Park - “In the End” (2000)
104. White Stripes - “Ball and Biscuit” (2003)
105. Death Cab for Cutie - “Transatlanticism” (2003)

106. Bartees Strange - “Boomer” (2020)
107. Boygenius - “Stay Down” (2018)
108. The Vines - “Get Free” (2002)

109. Black Sabbath - “God Is Dead?” (2013)
110. Bob Dylan - “Key West (Philosopher Pirate)” (2020)
111. The Darkness - “I Believe in a Thing Called Love” (2003)
112. Brandi Carlile - “The Story” (2007)
113. Elliott Smith - “L.A.” (2000)

114. Pearl Jam - “Got Some” (2009)
115. Gaslight Anthem - “The ’59 Sound” (2008)
116. Willow feat. Travis Barker - “Transparent Soul” (2021)
117. Nine Inch Nails - “The Hand That Feeds” (2005)
118. Silversun Pickups - “Lazy Eye” (2006)

119. Cameron Winter - “Love Takes Miles” (2024)
120. Benjamin Booker - “Violent Shiver” (2014)
121. My Chemical Romance - “I’m Not Okay (I Promise)” (2004)
122. Paul McCartney - “Fine Line” (2005)
123. Taking Back Sunday - “You’re So Last Summer” (2002)
124. John Mayer - “Slow Dancing in a Burning Room” (2006)
125. Gojira - “Flying Whales” (2005)
126. Spoon - “The Way We Get By” (2002)
127. Audioslave - “Like a Stone” (2002)

128. Gary Clark Jr. - “Bright Lights” (2011)
129. Sonic Youth - “Incinerate” (2006)
130. Harry Styles - “Kiwi” (2017)
131. Muse - “Uprising” (2009)
132. Japandroids - “The Nights of Wine and Roses” (2012)
133. Kings of Leon - “The Bucket” (2004)

134. Rush - “Headlong Flight” (2012)
135. The Killers - “Read My Mind” (2006)
136. The Stratford 4 - “Telephone” (2003)
137. Big Thief - “Not” (2019)
138. The Strokes - “Reptilia” (2003)

139. Neil Young and Crazy Horse - “Ramada Inn” (2012)
140. Arch Enemy - “We Will Rise” (2003)
141. Soccer Mommy - “Circle the Drain” (2020)
142. Low Cut Connie - “Revolution Rock n Roll” (2017)
143. Snail Mail - “Heat Wave” (2018)
144. Wolfmother - “Joker & the Thief” (2005)

145. Songs: Ohia - “Farewell Transmission” (2003)
146. Lou Reed - “Big Sky” (2000)
147. The Libertines - “Don’t Look Back Into the Sun” (2003)
148. Yo La Tengo - “Cherry Chapstick” (2000)

149. Meshuggah - “Bleed” (2008)
150. Bleachers - “Jesus Is Dead” (2024)
151. Kurt Vile - “Pretty Pimpin’” (2015)
152. Jet - “Are You Gonna Be My Girl” (2003)
153. Foo Fighters - “Best of You” (2005)

154. Boris with Michio Kurihara - “Rainbow” (2007)
155. Sky Ferreira - “You’re Not the One” (2013)
156. Prince - “Guitar” (2007)
157. Hop Along - “The Knock” (2015)
158. Gossip - “Standing in the Way of Control” (2006)
159. The Shins - “Caring Is Creepy” (2001)
160. Water From Your Eyes - “Barley” (2023)

161. Metallica - “Spit Out the Bone” (2016)
162. Ought - “Beautiful Blue Sky” (2015)
163. Sturgill Simpson - “Call to Arms” (2016)
164. Deerhunter - “Desire Lines” (2010)
165. Louis XIV - “Finding Out True Love Is Blind” (2005)
166. At the Drive-In - “Arcarsenal” (2000)
167. Jason Isbell and the 400 Unit - “Cumberland Gap” (2017)
168. Electric Six - “Danger! High Voltage” (2002)
169. The Rolling Stones - “Whole Wide World” (2023)

170. Sum 41 - “Fat Lip” (2001)
171. Mdou Moctar - “Afrique Victime” (2021)
172. The Monkees - “Me and Magdalena” (2016)
173. Blondshell - “Salad” (2023)
174. Future Islands - “Seasons (Waiting on You)” (2014)
175. Red Clay Strays - “Wondering Why” (2022)
176. King Gizzard and the Lizard Wizard - “Rattlesnake” (2017)
177. Alejandro Escovedo - “Castanets” (2001)
178. Sleigh Bells - “Rill Rill” (2010)
179. Moses Sumney - “Virile” (2019)
180. Downtown Boys - “Monstro” (2015)
181. Yungblud - “Hello Heaven, Hello” (2025)
182. Avril Lavigne - “My Happy Ending” (2004)
183. Bombino - “Amidinine” (2013)
184. Mudcrutch - “Crystal River” (2008)
185. Velvet Revolver - “Slither” (2004)
186. Tame Impala - “Elephant” (2012)

187. Slipknot - “People = ****” (2001)
188. The Raconteurs - “Steady, As She Goes” (2006)
189. Baroness - “Isak” (2007)
190. Alex G - “After Ur Gone” (2014)
191. Wolf Parade - “I’ll Believe in Anything” (2005)
192. Juanes - “Es Por Ti” (2002)
193. Momma - “Speeding 72” (2022)
194. Old 97’s - “Rollerskate Skinny” (2001)
195. The Mountain Goats - “This Year” (2005)
196. Incubus - “Circles” (2001)
197. Mogwai - “2 Rights Make 1 Wrong” (2001)
198. Speedy Ortiz - “The Graduates” (2015)
199. Noah Kahan - “American Cars” (2026)
200. Yellowcard - “Ocean Avenue” (2003)
 
Last edited:
These are my observations and opinions about the list:
- Obviously, all lists are kinda stupid, because it's trying to rank personal taste.
- But given that their job is to make lists, I think this generally highlights good songs/artists from the era.
- Some of the ordering is odd. The #1 is not ridiculous, but a bit arbitrary, while Tame Impala's Elephant (a logical #1 contender) is at 186.
- Numbers 2 and 3 are good. In fact, much of the top half is full of deserving songs, but they picked a bad representation for Radiohead at #5.
- Speaking of Radiohead, their entire "In Rainbows" album was left out, as were many other hits of theirs. The same can be said for Courtney Barnett, Tame Impala, St. Vincent, and other staples of the era. I can only guess that they had a rule about multiple entries from an artist.
- Given my observation above, I think the list is best used as a representation of artists of the era, rather than top songs.
 
Back
Top Bottom