Found this thread (which I started). I have to add "Is She Really Going Out with Him?" by Joe Jackson to this conversation. Not only is it sappy (and comes from a really rocking album), but it's a signature song for the band. Just like "Tempted" by Squeeze, "Brass in Pocket" by The Pretenders, and "Every Breath You Take" by The Police, these are all signature songs that most people use to associate with the band.
I can add "Dust in the Wind" by Kansas to that list. I kind of like the song, but it is sappy, very overplayed, and it's the only Kansas song many people know.