Rock 'n Roll HOF announces nominees

Question... because I don't know the answer.

Carly Simon is just being inducted this year. Bonnie Raitt was inducted way back in 2000.

Not a knock on Bonnie Raitt, because she's a talented legend. But prior to her string of hits in the early 1990's, did you guys know much of her music? I'm reading that she had critical success, but not much commercial success prior to 1990. Is that enough to warrant her getting the induction way before Carly Simon, who had way more chart success.

Just curious.
The simple answer is that it makes no sense, much like a lot of the selections. The Zombies got inducted at the same time as Green Day.

But regarding Raitt, she first became popular in the 70s, with songs like Runaway. However, she didn't score big until the late 80s.
 
KNX 93.1 in Los Angeles had a "mellow rock" format from 1971 to 1983 and played several Bonnie Raitt songs. I remember hearing Bluebird, Runaway, Too Long At The Fair, Sweet Forgiveness and a few others. But she didn't have a top-40 hit until 1991 (Something To Talk About) and only one of her songs made the country chart, Don't It Make Ya Wanna Dance in 1980. Chart success should be the biggest factor in who gets inducted into the Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame – and when. I think the judges must be using a Magic 8 Ball. Bonnie Raitt? "It is certain." Carly Simon? "Outlook not so good." Jethro Tull? "Ask again later."

1652322103187.jpeg
 
I consider Jethro Tull to be progressive rock, not heavy metal. What heavy metal bands have a flute player? And AC/DC, Aerosmith, Kiss, Metallica, Black Sabbath, Def Leppard, Bon Jovi and Guns N' Roses are in the Hall Of Fame. Jethro Tull deserves to be there too. They've had 13 top-20 albums and two number ones (Thick As A Brick and A Passion Play) and they've been eligible for 29 years!
 
Jethro Tull was given a Grammy for the Heavy Metal category in 1989 beating Metallica. So they HAVE to be a metal band. It’s not like we can expect an established institution to make a mistake like that.

FWIW, Dolly Parton successfully turned down the nomination.
 
I know "I Can't Make You Love Me" real well. I bought the CD single back in the day. I like (and liked) it more than "Something To Talk About".

Here's a slice of my favorite songs list from 1992 (as documented back then):

15 The KLF “Last Train to Trancentral”
16 Tom Cochrane “Life is a Highway”
17 Metallica “Nothing Else Matters”

18 Bonnie Raitt “I Can’t Make You Love Me”
19 Kriss Kross “Jump”
20 Naughty by Nature “O.P.P.”
 
Jethro Tull was given a Grammy for the Heavy Metal category in 1989 beating Metallica. So they HAVE to be a metal band. It’s not like we can expect an established institution to make a mistake like that.
This is 100% true, and it was notable because it was the 1st year they added that category.

No, I just never heard the other ones.
Another shocking admission.

Bonnie Raitt (Hot 100)
#5 "Something To Talk About"
#18 "I Can't Make You Love Me"
#19 "Love Sneakin' Up On You"
#33 "You Got It"
#34 "Not the Only One"
As I've mentioned in my thread, I have every one of these albums. I think I have 5 of her CDs. BTW, You Got It is a cover of an old song.
 
Question... because I don't know the answer.

Carly Simon is just being inducted this year. Bonnie Raitt was inducted way back in 2000.

Not a knock on Bonnie Raitt, because she's a talented legend. But prior to her string of hits in the early 1990's, did you guys know much of her music? I'm reading that she had critical success, but not much commercial success prior to 1990. Is that enough to warrant her getting the induction way before Carly Simon, who had way more chart success.

Just curious.
Before Thing Called Love I had some idea who she was but only heard one song. In this case she’s like Dolly in that she counts as an influence on a lot of rock musicians early on.
 
I watched the virtual broadcast. Doobie Brothers was good, as was NIN, and Depeche Mode. T-Rex was ok.

Some of the people introducing the bands included Iggy Pop, Luke Bryan, Charlize Theron, Miley Cyrus, Billy Gibbons, and Judd Apatow.

They also inducted a manager and a producer (John Landau and Irv Azoff). One worked with the Eagles, and one with Springsteen.
Here's what Dave Gahan of Depeche Mode thinks about being inducted in the "Rock" Hall Of Fame

Gahan remembered how the last time that he, Gore and Fletcher appeared together before the latter’s death was when they were inducted into the Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame via Zoom back in 2020.

“We were probably the last band they wanted to have in there but they had to give it to us in the end!” said Gahan. “That was kind of nice; the feeling of all those rock’n’rollers looking down on us in disdain going, ‘This is not a rock’n’roll band!’ That had been a dispute for years, but that had to change.
 
Journey is in the HOF.
Foreigner has never even received a nomination.

Their resumes are similar.

Top 10 hits:
Journey 6
Foreigner 9

Top 40 hits:
Journey 19
Foreigner 16

Albums sold (U.S. only):
Journey 48 million
Foreigner 37.5 million

Putting preferences aside, do you see Journey as that much more historically relevant than Foreigner?
 
Back
Top Bottom